Membrane Solutions MSA3 Vs Winix 5500-2 – Comparison (2022)

The Membrane Solutions MSA3 is a relatively new air purifier on the market, while the Winix 5500-2 is a well-known, top-notch air purifier. In this article, you will find out whether the Membrane Solutions beat the unbeaten Winix 5500-2 air purifier. But, before diving into the article more deeply, let’s compare their basic specifications.

Membrane Solutions MSA3 Vs Winix 5500-2 - Air Purifiers Comparison

Winix 5500-2 is a large air purifier that covers rooms up to 360 sq. ft., while the Membrane Solutions MSA3 covers rooms up to 210 sq. ft. The Winix uses a four-stage filtration technology, and it has an ionizer, which is the fourth stage. Luckily the Winix 5500-2 is CARB certified, which means it doesn’t produce an unallowed amount of ozone. The Membrane Solutions, on the other hand, uses a three-stage filtration technology. It doesn’t have an ionizer and is 100% safe to use. 

When speaking of build quality, I must say that they both are of very good quality, and their construction is okay. The only complaint I have is the plastic on Membrane Solutions, which gets stains quickly. 

What else I want to say is that Winix has much more advanced features, from which I like the air quality sensor and auto mode the most. Membrane Solutions doesn’t have that many features but has just enough for everyday usage.

Keep reading and find out which one performed better in performance tests, which use less power, which is quieter, and which is a better buying option.

MSA3 Vs Winix 5500-2 Specifications

Membrane Solutions MSA3 air Purifier Winix 5500-2 Air Purifier
Manufacturer Membrane Solutions Winix
Model MSA3 5500-2
Dimensions 7.7 x 13.1 x 21.5 inches (19.5 x 33.4 x 54.5 cm) 15 x 8.2 x 23.6 inches
Room Coverage (4.8 ACH) 210 sq. ft. 360 sq. ft.
Performance Ratings
Filtration Technology Pre-filter, True HEPA Filter, and Carbon Filter Washable Pre-filter, Washable AOC Carbon Filter, and True HEPA Filter
Filter Replacement Indicator Yes Yes
Filter Longevity 3-6 months up to 12 months
Power 44W 70W
Operating Costs Ratings
Fan Speeds 3 – Speed 1, Speed 2, and Speed 3 5 – Sleep Mode, Speed 1, Speed 2, Speed 3, and Turbo Mode
Air Quality Sensor No Yes
Air Quality Indicator No Yes
Auto Mode No Yes
Remote Controller No Yes
Display Lock Yes No
Display Off Yes No
Noise Levels 43.1 – 54.3 dBA 40.6 – 66.4 dBA
Noise Ratings
Warranty 2-year 2-year
In-Depth Review Membrane Solutions MSA3 Winix 5500-2
Price Check Price on Amazon Check Price on Amazon
GermGuardian AC4825 Vs Membrane Solutions MSA3 Membrane Solutions MSA3 Vs Blueair 411 Related comparisons

Which One Does It Better?

After analyzing these two air purifiers’ aspects, I have concluded that the Winix 5500-2 is a much better buying option.

First of all, it uses much more quality filters, has many more features, is more affordable for maintenance annually, and did much better in performance tests. I believe these are enough reasons to choose the Winix 5500-2 as a better buying option.

If you have any questions about these two air purifiers, please leave a comment in the comment box below.

Leave a Reply